RASCAL is developing a very fast airplane they call their first stage. The second stage is a rocket that is 258 Kg empty and has 1865 Kg fuel. This is very close to the size of rocket in the SSTT concept here. RASCAL has a third stage that is 537 Kg total mass of which 50 to 100 Kg is payload. In the proposal here the tether is the third stage and everything the second stage can carry is payload. The table below has more comparisons.
Feature | Rascal | SSTT | Tradeoff |
Flight rate | 10/year | 14/day | SSTT can do reusable |
First stage | High Speed Aircraft | Proteus or RASCAL | Above atmosphere or cheaper vehicle |
Second stage | Rocket | Reusable rocket | Just fuel instead of new rockets |
Third stage | Rocket | Tether | Higher operating costs or higher initial costs |
Circularize orbit | Rocket | Aerobreaking/Space Tug | Expendable vs Reusable |
Development costs | $50 mil? | $500 mil? | New aircraft/rocket vs new rocket/tether |
Price per launch | $750,000 | $50,000 | Reusable costs less per launch |
Payload to orbit | 75 Kg | 250+ Kg | As tether gets bigger and faster rocket carries more |
Payload costs to LEO | $20,000/Kg | $50/Kg | Reusable is far cheaper |
Market | Small | Large | Lower cost gets bigger market |